Today's Story
A large dandelion-like plant which was thought to be nearly extinct in the state may actually be thriving. Scientists have recently uncovered the plant growing locations throughout Western Pennsylvania. Brad Linder has more.

Playing hide and seek with plants.
15 years ago, there was only one known Prenanthes Crepidinea (Preh-nan-thiss Krep-id-in-ee-uh) in Pennsylvania.
July 18, 2002

By Dan Simon

Habitat destruction, landscapers, browsing deer. There are a number of reasons why a plant species may become scare enough to merit the concern of the environmental community.

Another complication is that some plant species do best in places researchers have a lot of trouble reaching.

The Wildlife Resource Conservation Fund lists more than 350 plant species that are considered endangered or threatened in Pennsylvania. Many times though, it can be hard for even experts to have a good handle on a plant's status, as proved by the Rattlesnake Root's example.

"What happens is we start by doing field inventories," said Frank Felbaum, director of the office of the Wild Resource Conservation Fund. "We go to designated herbarium records, and see where the last of a type was validated."


Researchers examine what had been thought to be an extremely rare plant. A Carnegie Museum botanist has discovered the plant may actually number in the millions in Pennsylvania.

Those records will be 50 to 100 years old Felbaum said. The researchers then visit the recorded location.

"If successful, they will find a population," he explained. "If not, they'll find a Wal-Mart or church parking lot or playground. That's the first step. If in fact there are a very low number of occurrences of the plant in the state, then it is classified as endangered, threatened or as a candidate for protection."

Many of Pennsylvania's more than 2,200 species of native plants face a triple whammy. Development is probably the most visible culprit, but Felbaum brought up a pair of other threats.

"The natives are being out-competed by the exotic plants (non-native species), plus some of them have become the favorite bill of fare for the deer population," he explained.
"If you're a bald eagle being disturbed, you can pick up and leave. If you're a native plant threatened by a bulldozer, you're dead. So if you find one has survived in this remote location, maybe it's because it's filled a niche. It's someplace where deer can't get at it, it's not a location for development, and it's not close enough to anything to bring exotics, so it's able to be successful."

Of course such places are also remote enough and hard enough to reach that researchers have trouble getting there too.


Rattlesnake Root (Prenanthes Crepidinea) Photo by Bonnie Issac

"You may have to drive an hour, then hike five or six miles into the woods to try and find a site from one of these 50-year-old records," he said. "And then it might be the wrong time of year to even see the plant."

Several more problems make the plant researcher's job even harder. Many plants' life cycles are such that they may only be visible during brief periods each year-or worse, every other year. There also aren't many researchers looking. The state has a native wild plants committee made up of about 25 professionals, Felbaum said.

"They're kind of a botanical 'A' team," he said. "Plus there's probably more people-college botany professors for example-looking as well, but there's no set organization for people outside the committee."

To make matters worse, the best information available on many of these plants is, in a word, incomplete.

"We don't know enough about plant developmental factors," Felbaum said. "How do you get that information on 2,200 plants? There's a multitude of issues for plants, they don't just have a litter each year.

"Our budget is only about a half million dollars a year. That only scratches the surface. It should be twice that."

Then there are the plants that require something approaching pure luck to figure out.
Felbaum described the efforts of a researcher who'd spent years searching for a rare Chester County, Penn., plant.

"She was visiting a horse pasture looking for a completely different plant," he said. "Suddenly she glimpsed a blue flower out of the corner of her eye. It turned out to be the plant she'd been searching for, for years."

An even more extreme example shows just how patient botanists need to be.
"When Lake Erie was down the last two years we weren't seeing a lot of a particular plant," he recalled. "The Long Low Arrowhead showed up, but there were only about 18 of them. Then, once the lakeshore's mud became dry and hard enough, over a thousand plants appeared."

Felbaum explained a natural form of "seed banking" was taking place with the species. The plants released seeds that would stay dormant while under water and won't grow until conditions are just right.

"This was the lowest level of Erie in something like a hundred years I think," he said. "Sometimes nature has a way of taking care of things."


Today's Story
Hear Brad Linder's Radio Report.

Additional story
More on the Rattlesnake Root.

Radio Story Transcript
Read Brad's story.

Western Pennsylvania Conservancy
An organization dedicated to preserving Western Pennsylvania's natural heritage.

Wild Resources Conservation Fund
Has information about Pennsylvania's endangered species.

Carnegie Museum
Their press release announcing the Rattlesnake Root may be thriving after all.




The Environmental Reporter is a partnership of GreenWorks.tv and WHYY Radio, which makes all reports available to public radio stations throughout Pennsylvania.