Today's Story
Erie is one of the last major cities in Pennsylvania that does not put fluoride in its drinking water. After years of public debate, the city will begin adding fluoride this fall. But there are still some in the area who would rather not put extra chemicals in the water supply. Brad Linder has more.

Fluoride
Choosing your fluoride exposure.
August 30, 2002

By Dan Simon

It's been controversial for more than 40 years now. The argument over whether drinking water should be fluoridated or not is probably one that's just not going to go away.

Opponents say fluoridation can lead to a host of health problems, including
thyroid disorders, cancer, organ failure and doesn't even help prevent cavities. Proponents say fluoridation has done wonders in helping to prevent tooth decay, particularly in poor children who don't receive regular dental care.

Each side is persuasive. Each side is loaded with its facts and figures. So what's a concerned person to do?

One suggestion would be to take control over the products you consume. You can either filter fluoride and other possible contaminants from your drinking water, or chose bottled water that's free of fluoride instead. Just be aware that many bottled drinks may have also been prepared using fluoridated water. If you're going to take the filtering approach, make sure the filter system you use will actually remove fluoride from your water, not all commercially available water filters do.

Or do you feel fluoride is a good thing, but just don't want the kind that's added to drinking water (a byproduct of the phosphate fertilizer industry). If you're all right with the idea of food-grade fluoride as part of your approach to dental hygiene, then using a fluoride toothpaste can satisfy your needs while you avoid the stuff in tap water.

Finally, if you're a huge believer in the stuff and aren't getting it from your well or municipal water supply, several companies are now offering fluoridated bottled water.

The choice is yours.


Today's Story
Hear Brad Linder's Radio Report.

Additional Story
More information.

Brad's Transcript
Read Brad's radio story.

Additional Soundbite
Jim Rudy is chief operating officer of the Erie City Water Authority. He says his children grew up with Fluoridated water, and their teeth have outlasted his own because of it.

Additional Soundbite 2
Dentist David Shapter says fluoride doesn't always have to be added to water to have an impact.

Centers for Disease Control
Federal agency web site.

American Dental Association
The fluoride debate.

The Pen Fluoridation Leadership Team
Fluoridation opponent web site.





The Environmental Reporter is a partnership of GreenWorks.tv and WHYY Radio, which makes all reports available to public radio stations throughout Pennsylvania.