Today's Story
More than half of all Pennsylvanians getting drinking water from public water supplies are also getting a small dose of fluoride. Health officials have said fluoridation is one of the most successful public health programs of the last century, but across the state, there are still many communities that do not add fluoride. WHYY's Brad Linder has more.

More Fluoride
Debate over fluoridation goes on.
October 16, 2002

By Dan Simon

It's a controversial subject.

The issue of whether or not to put fluoride in drinking water supplies has generated conspiracy theories worthy of an X-Files or James Bond script in a debate where neither side will give an inch.

The idea of adding fluoride to drinking water supplies dates back the beginnings of the last century when public health officials noticed western states that had high levels of fluoride in their drinking water, also had low levels of tooth decay. This led to a national effort to add fluoride to water supplies.

Fluoride is a naturally occurring element that is a gas in its normal form. The substance doesn't become a solid until it forms a compound with other elements. In large quantities it's poisonous to human beings.

Those in support of fluoride argue it serves to strengthen the tooth's enamel, by making its mineral composition stronger and so, less likely to decay.

Those against the use of fluoride in drinking water supplies maintain that while high-grade fluoride, such as the kind found in toothpaste, is alright, the type of fluoride being added to the water is actually a chemical waste product from other uses and not fit for human consumption.

The United States Public Health Service (USPHS) considers a range from 0.7 to 1.2 parts per million as the optimum concentration for fluoride in United States drinking water supplies. One part per million is roughly the same as one minute in a two-year period or a penny out of a $10,000.

Today's Story
Hear Brad's Radio Report.

Additional Story
Conflicting views in the fluoride debate point out the pros and cons of this issue.

Transcript
Read Brad's radio story.

Additional Story Transcript
Read opposing viewpoints in the fluoride debate.

Fluoride
Environmental Reporter

National Center for Fluoridation Policy and Research
Fluoridation proponent web site.

Pen Fluoridation Leadership Team
Pennsylvania based fluoridation opponent

American Dental Association
Fluoridation proponent web site.

Fluoride Action Network
Fluoridation opponent web site.




The Environmental Reporter is a partnership of GreenWorks.tv and WHYY Radio, which makes all reports available to public radio stations throughout Pennsylvania.